From 8bc5f9439d37752828cb18e8ea9a185a94c31ad1 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Noel Sabia Date: Fri, 13 Nov 2026 18:29:16 +0100 Subject: [PATCH] feat: add preselection selection criteria Document the idea and implementation criteria used to select teams for the final jury pitch, add a criteria-evidence checklist, and link the criteria from the event indexes. --- knowledge/events/index.md | 2 +- knowledge/events/preselection-prepitch.md | 44 ++++++++++++++++++++--- knowledge/index.md | 2 +- knowledge/log.md | 1 + 4 files changed, 43 insertions(+), 6 deletions(-) diff --git a/knowledge/events/index.md b/knowledge/events/index.md index 8e7d35d..0870879 100644 --- a/knowledge/events/index.md +++ b/knowledge/events/index.md @@ -1,3 +1,3 @@ # Event logistics -* [Preselection / pre-pitch](preselection-prepitch.md) - Sunday schedule: pitch, demonstrate, submit the final presentation and code by 13:00, then preselection for the final jury pitch. +* [Preselection / pre-pitch](preselection-prepitch.md) - Sunday schedule and selection criteria: pitch, demonstrate, submit the final presentation and code by 13:00, then preselection for the final jury pitch. diff --git a/knowledge/events/preselection-prepitch.md b/knowledge/events/preselection-prepitch.md index 8c7c33d..c8cb910 100644 --- a/knowledge/events/preselection-prepitch.md +++ b/knowledge/events/preselection-prepitch.md @@ -1,10 +1,10 @@ --- type: Hackathon Event title: "Preselection | TechCampus — Sunday pre-pitch" -description: Sunday preselection schedule for the Future City Hackathon 2026, including the pitch mission, the 13:00 submission deadline, and advancement to the final jury pitch. -tags: [event, future-city-hackathon-2026, preselection, prepitch, pitching, judging, techcampus] +description: Sunday preselection schedule for the Future City Hackathon 2026, including the pitch mission, the selection criteria, the 13:00 submission deadline, and advancement to the final jury pitch. +tags: [event, future-city-hackathon-2026, preselection, prepitch, pitching, judging, criteria, techcampus] status: stable -generated: { by: opencode/deepseek-v4.1-flash, at: 2026-11-13T17:26:56Z } +generated: { by: opencode/deepseek-v4.1-flash, at: 2026-11-13T17:28:07Z } --- # At a glance @@ -16,6 +16,7 @@ generated: { by: opencode/deepseek-v4.1-flash, at: 2026-11-13T17:26:56Z } | Format | In-person pitch, live demonstration, and explanation | | Submission deadline | 13:00 — stop hacking and submit the final presentation and code | | Outcome | Each challenge provider selects the best solution from its teams; the selected team advances to the final pitch in front of the jury | +| Selection criteria | **Idea:** problem and benefit, originality, feasibility and future. **Implementation:** reliability, understanding of your own solution, teamwork, documentation, choice of technology. | | Preparation | Arrange a time slot with your challenge provider on Saturday; bring a pitch deck and a working version of the solution | # Schedule @@ -37,8 +38,32 @@ To do that: - Arrange your time slot with your challenge provider on Saturday. - Have your pitch deck and a working version of your solution ready. +# Selection criteria + +The preselection slide groups the criteria into two parts. It names the criteria only; the guidance column is an interpretation to help prepare the pitch. + +## Part A — The idea + +| Criterion | What to demonstrate | +|---|---| +| Problem and Benefit | The problem is real, the target user is clear, and the solution creates a benefit worth caring about. | +| Originality | The idea is distinctive rather than a generic dashboard or an off-the-shelf wrapper. | +| Feasibility and Future | The solution can realistically be built and operated, and it has a credible path beyond the hackathon. | + +## Part B — The implementation + +| Criterion | What to demonstrate | +|---|---| +| Reliability | The demo works consistently, including with realistic data and conditions. | +| Understanding of Your Own Solution | The team can explain how it works, why it works, and where it breaks. | +| Teamwork | The team can show how it collaborated, divided the work, and integrated the pieces. | +| Documentation | The code, setup, and approach are documented clearly enough for someone else to understand and run. | +| Choice of Technology | The technology fits the problem, the data, and the deployment constraints. | + # Checklist +## Logistics + - [ ] Time slot arranged with the challenge provider on Saturday. - [ ] Pitch deck ready. - [ ] Working solution ready to demonstrate. @@ -46,6 +71,17 @@ To do that: - [ ] Final presentation and code submitted at 13:00. - [ ] Team present in person for the preselection. +## Criteria evidence + +- [ ] A clear problem statement and user benefit. +- [ ] A clear statement of what is original about the idea. +- [ ] Evidence that the solution is feasible and has a future path. +- [ ] A reliable live demonstration. +- [ ] A clear explanation of how the solution works and where it fails. +- [ ] A short teamwork story. +- [ ] Documentation ready to hand over. +- [ ] A justification for the technology choices. + # How the preselection works Each challenge provider selects the best solution from the teams working on its challenge. The selected team advances to the final pitch in front of the jury. @@ -65,4 +101,4 @@ The slide says "Sunday" and "Saturday" but does not print calendar dates. The 20 # Source -The schedule comes from the organizer's "Preselection | TechCampus" slide, supplied on 2026-11-13. No file copy of the slide is stored in this repository. +The schedule comes from the organizer's "Preselection | TechCampus" slide, and the criteria come from the "Criteria Preselection" slide. Both were supplied on 2026-11-13. No file copies of the slides are stored in this repository. diff --git a/knowledge/index.md b/knowledge/index.md index 7ed18bf..262c25c 100644 --- a/knowledge/index.md +++ b/knowledge/index.md @@ -17,7 +17,7 @@ Six partner organizations brought one challenge each to the Future City Hackatho # Event logistics -* [Preselection / pre-pitch](events/preselection-prepitch.md) - Sunday schedule: pitch, demonstrate, submit the final presentation and code by 13:00, then preselection for the final jury pitch. +* [Preselection / pre-pitch](events/preselection-prepitch.md) - Sunday schedule and selection criteria: pitch, demonstrate, submit the final presentation and code by 13:00, then preselection for the final jury pitch. # Datasets diff --git a/knowledge/log.md b/knowledge/log.md index bb2f9fb..f04535d 100644 --- a/knowledge/log.md +++ b/knowledge/log.md @@ -7,5 +7,6 @@ * **Creation**: Added dataset concepts for the HNVG LoRaWAN package, the PreZero glass fill levels, and the Stadt Heilbronn media mention export. * **Creation**: Added organizer concepts for all six partner organizations and linked them to their challenges. * **Creation**: Added the preselection / pre-pitch event concept with the Sunday schedule and 13:00 submission deadline. +* **Update**: Added the preselection criteria for the idea and implementation, plus a criteria-evidence checklist. * **Update**: Expanded the Schwarz Digits challenge with the advertising, store-location, staffing, STACKIT deployment, and example-view details from the challenge deck. * **Note**: All concepts are agent-generated and unverified. Source documents remain in their original folders at the repository root.