Fill route and cooling-gap screening results in Cool City paper

This commit is contained in:
Noel Sabia committed 2026-11-14 13:08:28 +01:00
1 parent 8e598dea25
commit b43ad97d5e
5 files changed
+68 -55

No files matched your search

+67 -54
View File
@@ -1,13 +1,13 @@
# Cool City: A Public Heat-Safe Route and Cooling-Gap Layer for Heilbronn
# Cool City: A Public Heat-Safe Route and Cooling-Gap Screening Layer for Heilbronn
**Author:** Noel Sabia (ORCID 0009-0008-3064-7573)
**Affiliation:** —
**Date:** 14 November 2026
**Prototype:** https://pulse.noelsabia.dev · **Cool City route:** `/cool` (bundle TBD) · **DOI:** TBD
**Prototype:** https://pulse.noelsabia.dev · **Cool City route:** `/cool` · **DOI:** TBD
## Abstract
Heat is a measurable public-health threat, and Heilbronn already knows where its cool places are, but not how a person reaches them. Cool City is a public heat-safe route built on the existing eight-sensor pulse. A weather-aware global model forecasts the relative footfall index, reaching MAE 3.32, WAPE 27.5%, and R² 0.777 on a 28-day holdout versus 5.40, 44.7%, and 0.462 for a seasonal-naive baseline. A route and shade layer combines OpenStreetMap walkable ways, the city tree cadastre, and solar position to offer shortest, shaded, and accessible routes with modeled shade coverage, direct-sun minutes, step-free continuity, water, and benches. A cooling-gap layer ranks the eight sensor catchments by relative footfall, shade deficit, access deficit, and—where sourced—vulnerability. The existing retail staffing plan remains one commercial application. Shade is modeled, the cooling gap is relative rather than a measured temperature, and the underlying pulse is estimated devices, not people; route and city values are TBD until the route/shade bundle is frozen.
Heat is a measurable public-health threat, and Heilbronn already knows where its cool places are, but not how a person reaches them. Cool City is a public heat-safe route built on the existing eight-sensor pulse. A weather-aware global model forecasts the relative footfall index, reaching MAE 3.32, WAPE 27.5%, and R² 0.777 on a 28-day holdout versus 5.40, 44.7%, and 0.462 for a seasonal-naive baseline. On a clear 35.0 °C day (14 August 2026), the route layer combines OpenStreetMap walkable ways, the city tree cadastre, and solar geometry to model three routes from Stadtgalerie to Marktplatz: shortest 359.5 m / 4.8 min, shaded 732.3 m / 9.8 min, and accessible 438.2 m / 5.8 min. At 16:00 the accessible route is recommended for Ruth: 43.8% modeled shade, 3.3 direct-sun minutes, no ramp, and water and benches. The shaded route has a higher shade share (50.0%) but, being twice as long, more direct sun (4.9 min); shade share alone is misleading. A relative socio-spatial screening index ranks the eight 300 m catchments with weights 0.40 footfall, 0.30 shade deficit, 0.20 access deficit, and 0.10 vulnerability; Hagenbuchersee 2 ranks first (0.6471). Vulnerability is the 17.26% 65+ share of Heilbronn Innenstadt (31.12.2016) and is constant across all eight, so it does not differentiate them. Shade is modeled, the screening index is relative rather than a measured heat map, and the pulse is estimated devices, not people.
## 1. Problem
@@ -17,7 +17,7 @@ The city already publishes **almost 60 cool places** on a map, with an address l
This is not a city that has done nothing. Heilbronn adopted a climate-adaptation concept in April 2023 with 31 measures across five fields [8] and published a 2025 spatial climate-adaptation concept [9]. The gap is narrower and more actionable: **the person-level route**. The city knows where the cool places are; it does not yet give a person a safe way there, hour by hour, with the access needs that determine whether the route is usable.
The existing eight-sensor pulse is the evidence spine, but it is a **relative device index**, not a count of people. Cool City does not hide that. It uses the index to forecast relative demand and to rank cooling gaps, and it states the measurement limits wherever a decision depends on them. The contribution is the public decision layer over a noisy city index: three routes for a persona, a relative cooling-gap ranking for the city, and the retail staffing plan as one commercial tenant.
The existing eight-sensor pulse is the evidence spine, but it is a **relative device index**, not a count of people. Cool City does not hide that. It uses the index to forecast relative demand and to screen relative cooling gaps, and it states the measurement limits wherever a decision depends on them. The contribution is the public decision layer over a noisy city index: three routes for a persona, a relative socio-spatial screening ranking for the city, and the retail staffing plan as one commercial tenant.
## 2. Data and measurement audit
@@ -40,69 +40,81 @@ The forecast is a global `HistGradientBoostingRegressor` trained on hourly means
*Table 1. The measurement audit. Cool City inherits every limit in this table; it does not turn the index into people or into temperature.*
![Figure 1. Forecast versus actual.](figures/fig_forecast.png)
*Figure 1. Forecast versus actual for one sensor over the 28-day holdout. The model captures the daily/weekly shape but misses spikes; the band is a planning aid, not a calibrated 95% interval unless coverage is reported.*
## 3. Cool City
### 3.1 A person, three routes, and a clock
The demo persona is **Ruth, 78, who lives alone**. She is a clearly labelled composite, not a real person; the prototype can later use a real local story with consent. Her trip is **Stadtgalerie → Marktplatz**: short, ordinary, and exactly the kind of trip that heat turns into a risk. The route geometry and place names must be verified on OSM before the demo.
The demo persona is **Ruth, 78, who lives alone**. She is a clearly labelled composite, not a real person; the prototype can later use a real local story with consent. Her trip is **Stadtgalerie → Marktplatz**: short, ordinary, and exactly the kind of trip that heat turns into a risk. Both endpoints and all street names are OSM-verified. The routes start at the OSM-tagged main entrance of Stadtgalerie on the east side (the official address point is on the west side) and end at the centre of Marktplatz.
Cool City offers three routes:
1. **Shortest** — the fastest path, with no shade or access preference.
2. **Shaded** — the cool route via the Deutschhof passage / Kiliansplatz (verify the exact geometry).
3. **Accessible** — a route that prefers step-free continuity, water, benches, and toilets (verify tags and continuity).
1. **Shortest** — the direct path via Deutschhofstraße, Fleiner Straße, Kirchbrunnenstraße, and Windgasse.
2. **Shaded** — the detour via the unnamed shaded tunnel at the Deutschhof, the Deutschhof courtyard, and Kiliansplatz.
3. **Accessible** — the step-free route via Sülmerstraße and Falkenstraße that avoids the Marktplatz tram ramp.
A time slider at **10:00, 12:00, 14:00, and 16:00** changes the recommendation as the sun moves. Each route card shows modeled shade coverage, direct-sun minutes, distance, duration, step-free status, water stops, and bench stops. The shade values are **modeled**, not measured. The audience vote is a comprehension device, not a data source: the room picks a route for Ruth, and the stage shows the split next to the model’s recommendation. Most people take the shortest; the model takes the cool, accessible one.
The shaded route uses the real OSM tunnel between Eichgasse and the Deutschhof courtyard. OSM has no signed name for it, so the bundle calls it “the shaded passage” and marks the name unverified; “Deutschhof”, “Taubenbrunnen”, and “Kiliansplatz” are OSM-verified. The courtyard is a dead end in OSM—the east/south passage is `access=no` and the north-east gate is `locked=yes`—so the route enters and leaves through the same tunnel. That out-and-back is why it is about twice as long as the shortest option.
A time slider at **10:00, 12:00, 14:00, and 16:00** changes the recommendation as the sun moves. Each route card shows modeled shade coverage, direct-sun minutes, distance, duration, step-free status, water stops, and bench stops. The shade values are **modeled**, not measured. The audience vote is a comprehension device, not a data source: the room picks a route for Ruth, and the stage shows the split next to the model’s recommendation. Most people take the shortest; the model recommends the accessible route on access grounds, not because it has the least sun.
### 3.2 Route and shade model
The route layer uses the OpenStreetMap walkable network (footways, pedestrian streets, paths, steps, crossings, buildings, trees, benches, drinking water, toilets, and wheelchair tags; ODbL) [10], the city tree cadastre from January 2026 (crown diameter; dl-de/by-2.0) [5], and solar position for the selected hour. Buildings and tree crowns cast modeled shade; the route cost combines travel time with penalties for direct sun, steps, and missing water/bench stops:
The route layer uses the OpenStreetMap walkable network (footways, pedestrian streets, paths, steps, crossings, buildings, trees, benches, drinking water, toilets, and wheelchair and kerb tags; ODbL) [10], the city tree cadastre from January 2026 (crown diameter; dl-de/by-2.0) [5], and solar position for the selected hour. `access=no`/`private` ways and locked gates are excluded; steps and `wheelchair=no` ways are forbidden for the accessible route. The bundle covers 854 main building footprints—6 have a `height` tag and 403 have `building:levels`, so **445 use a type default** (the 12 m default for `building=yes` alone covers 314)—and 801 trees: 795 cadastre trees plus 102 OSM trees, deduplicated within 6 m. Tree canopy height is modeled as `min(4.5 + 0.45 × crown_dm, 14) m` and radius as `crown_dm/2`; tree heights are not measured.
Buildings are swept along the shadow vector `height / tan(altitude)`; tree canopies are modeled as horizontal discs offset by `canopy_height / tan(altitude)`. Routes are sampled every 5 m, and a sample counts as shaded if it falls inside a building or tree shadow or on a way tagged `covered=yes`/`tunnel=yes`. Walking speed is constant at **1.25 m/s**, and `direct_sun_min = duration_min × (1 − shade_pct/100)`. Shade is clear-sky geometry: cloud cover is reported but not applied. The model is not a temperature model—it reports shade coverage and direct-sun minutes, not “degrees cooler.”
| Route | Distance / duration | 16:00 modeled shade | Direct sun 16:00 | Detour vs shortest | Step-free | Water / benches |
|---|---|---:|---:|---:|---|---|
| Shortest | 359.5 m / 4.8 min | 43.8% | 2.7 min | 0 m | Yes, but 15% ramp | 2 / 8 |
| Shaded | 732.3 m / 9.8 min | 50.0% | 4.9 min | +372.8 m (+103.7%) | Yes, but 15% ramp | 2 / 9 |
| Accessible | 438.2 m / 5.8 min | 43.8% | 3.3 min | +78.7 m (+21.9%) | Yes, no ramp | 2 / 6 |
*Table 2. Route cards on the clear hot day 2026-08-14 (max 35.0 °C; 0% cloud at all four hours). Shade is modeled, not measured. Water = public drinking-water points within 30 m; benches = OSM benches within 40 m.*
![Figure 1. Three routes from Stadtgalerie to Marktplatz.](figures/fig_cool_routes.png)
*Figure 1. The three routes on the OSM base network (14 November 2026 snapshot; ODbL). Grey = buildings and walkable ways, green dots = tree cadastre and OSM trees. The shaded route’s final approach overlaps the accessible route and is drawn dashed. The map is illustrative; the metrics come from the 5 m shade model.*
At **10:00** the shortest route has 61.6% shade and 1.8 direct-sun minutes, the shaded route 61.5% and 3.8 minutes, and the accessible route 67.4% and 1.9 minutes. The accessible route has the highest shade share in the morning, but the shortest route still has slightly less total sun because it is 1.0 minute shorter. At **14:00** shade falls to 27.4% (shortest), 42.6% (shaded), and 30.3% (accessible), with 3.5, 5.6, and 4.0 direct-sun minutes. At **16:00** the shaded route has the highest shade share, 50.0%, but 4.9 direct-sun minutes.
**The shaded route is not the lowest total sun exposure.** It has the highest shade share at 14:00 and 16:00, but it is 2.04× the shortest distance, so its total direct-sun minutes are higher at all four times. The shortest route is lowest at all four times (ties with the accessible route at 12:00). The accessible route is recommended for Ruth because it avoids the **15% rolled-kerb ramp** at the Marktplatz tram crossing (`node/12946835801`, `kerb=rolled`, `ramp:wheelchair=yes`, `incline=15.0%`), which the shortest and shaded routes use. The accessible route enters Marktplatz from the north via Sülmerstraße/Falkenstraße and returns **no kerb or ramp nodes** in the accessibility audit. Against the shortest route it costs **+78.7 m (+21.9%), +1.0 min, and +0.6 direct-sun minutes at 16:00**, in exchange for no ramp, two water stops, and six benches. The last 34 m on Marktplatz is `surface=sett` (cobblestone): step-free, but not a smooth-surface guarantee. The recommendation is an access preference, not a claim that the route is coolest.
### 3.3 Cooling-gap screening index
The city layer uses the eight sensor catchments, each a **300 m Euclidean radius** (282,743 m², about a 4-minute walk at 75 m/min) [6]. It computes a **relative socio-spatial screening index** as a weighted sum:
```text
cost(route) = travel_time
+ λ_sun × direct_sun_minutes
+ λ_step × step_free_penalty
+ λ_water × water_gap
Gap = 0.40 × footfall
+ 0.30 × shade_deficit
+ 0.20 × access_deficit
+ 0.10 × vulnerability
```
The weights `λ` and the route bundle are **TBD** until the route/shade data is frozen. The route is not a temperature model: it reports shade coverage and direct-sun minutes, not “degrees cooler.” A temperature claim would require a validated radiant-temperature model and field data. The exact route metrics are also TBD; Table 2 defines the slots they will fill.
The footfall, shade, and access components are min–max normalized across the eight catchments; vulnerability is a raw 0–1 share. `footfall` is the published relative device index, scored as 0.4 × min–max(mean) + 0.6 × min–max(p95) because peak footfall coincides with peak heat; its unit, metric, and aggregation interval are **not documented by the API**, so the semantics are assumed. `shade_deficit` is 1 minus a shade score: 0.5 × min(1, building footprint share / 0.45) + 0.5 × min(1, tree canopy share / 0.25), with 0.45 and 0.25 as planning heuristics. This is a **footprint/canopy proxy**, not measured shade and not the route-level shadow model. `access_deficit` is 0.35 water + 0.20 bench + 0.25 toilet + 0.20 step-free, each normalized as `min(distance, 300 m) / 300 m`; step-free is the distance to the nearest `wheelchair=yes` POI or official accessible toilet, not a routed barrier-free path. `vulnerability` is the raw 65+ share for Heilbronn Innenstadt, **17.26% (5,667 / 32,834, 31.12.2016)**. It is **constant across all eight catchments**, so it adds 0.01726 to every score and does **not differentiate them**; the ranking is driven by footfall, shade, and access.
| Route | Character | Shade coverage | Direct-sun min | Detour | Step-free | Water / bench stops |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Shortest | Fastest path | TBD | TBD | 0 by definition | TBD | TBD |
| Shaded | Via Deutschhof / Kiliansplatz (verify) | TBD | TBD | TBD | TBD | TBD |
| Accessible | Step-free, water, benches (verify) | TBD | TBD | TBD | TBD | TBD |
| Rank | Catchment | Gap score | Main driver |
|---:|---|---:|---|
| 1 | Hagenbuchersee 2 | 0.6471 | Footfall, shade, and access above median; p95 64.4, canopy 1.8%, water 236.5 m |
| 2 | Stadtgalerie | 0.6306 | Highest peak footfall (p95 67.2); building shade 42.4%, water 124.2 m |
| 3 | Neckarufer | 0.6069 | p95 61.6, canopy 2.5%, water 208.1 m |
| 4 | Hagenbuchersee 1 | 0.4979 | Canopy 1.2%, toilet 162.4 m, p95 49.7 |
| 5 | Marahaus | 0.3752 | Water 233.6 m, canopy 4.7%, p95 38.5 |
| 6 | Soleo | 0.3433 | Lowest footfall score (0.025); high shade and access deficits |
| 7 | Götzenturm | 0.2931 | Low footfall score (0.064) |
| 8 | Density 01 | 0.2660 | Lowest footfall (0.000); battery 11 |
*Table 2. Route cards. Values are TBD until the route/shade bundle is frozen; the paper does not invent route metrics.*
*Table 3. Top-gap ranking under the base weights 0.40 / 0.30 / 0.20 / 0.10. Ranks 1 and 2 differ by 0.0165 (2.5%) and are treated as co-priority. Vulnerability is constant across all eight, so the ordering is driven by footfall, shade, and access. This is a relative socio-spatial screening index, not a measured heat map.*
![Figure 2. OSM walkable network in the focus area.](figures/fig_cool_base.png)
*Figure 2. OpenStreetMap base network for the focus area (14 November 2026 snapshot; ODbL). Orange = footway, red = pedestrian street, purple = steps, grey = buildings, green = trees, blue = drinking water, brown = benches, pink crosses = labelled anchor places. This is a base network, not the final route or shade layer.*
### 3.3 Cooling-gap index
The city layer uses the eight sensor catchments (300–500 m). It computes a **relative cooling-gap index**:
```text
CG = normalize(footfall) × normalize(shade deficit)
× normalize(access deficit) × normalize(vulnerability)
```
`footfall` is the published relative device index; `shade deficit` comes from the modeled shade layer; `access deficit` combines missing water, benches, step-free continuity, and toilets; `vulnerability` is included **only where sourced** and is otherwise set to 1. Population by age is available at planning-district level [6], and disability statistics are citywide (11,730 people in 2023; the city says “almost 12,000”) [7]. Those are aggregate inputs, not block-level diagnoses. The index is normalized 0–1 and shown as a rank with a one-line reason. The weights and the final ranking are **TBD** until the city bundle is frozen. It is a relative model, not a measured temperature map, and it must not be presented as a city-wide heatmap.
The top-3 set—Hagenbuchersee 2 (0.6471), Stadtgalerie (0.6306), Neckarufer (0.6069)—is stable under equal, shade-heavy, and access-heavy weights; only ranks 2 and 3 swap under shade-heavy weighting. Shade deficits cluster in a narrow 0.500–0.651 band, so footfall and access drive most rank differences. The index is relative to these eight inner-city sensors only: all lie within ~585 m of each other, 300 m catchments overlap by up to **87.8%**, and there is no outer-district coverage. **All eight catchments are inner city; this is not a citywide neighbourhood ranking.** Citywide disability statistics (11,730 people in 2023; the city says “almost 12,000”) [7] are too coarse for catchment-level differentiation. The index is **not a measured temperature or heat map** and must not be presented as one.
### 3.4 Retail staffing as one application
The existing staffing plan remains a separate module. The same forecast schedules store staff; a retailer pays for that module. In this paper it is a commercial tenant, not the hero. The live plan is currently a snapshot with unstable scenario/window behavior, so we do not report its plan numbers here; the module is described qualitatively until the plan window and scenarios are stabilized. The Cool City paper’s contribution is the public route and cooling-gap layer, not a retailer dashboard.
The existing staffing plan remains a separate module. The same forecast schedules store staff; a retailer pays for that module. In this paper it is a commercial tenant, not the hero. The live plan is currently a snapshot with unstable scenario/window behavior, so we do not report its plan numbers here; the module is described qualitatively until the plan window and scenarios are stabilized. The Cool City paper’s contribution is the public route and screening layer, not a retailer dashboard.
## 4. Evaluation
**Route-level metrics.** The route evaluation will report shade coverage (%), direct-sun minutes, detour versus the shortest route, step-free continuity, water stops, and bench stops for each route at each time. All values are **TBD** until the route/shade bundle is frozen. The target direction is explicit: more shade, fewer direct-sun minutes, acceptable detour, continuous step-free access, and at least one water/bench option on the accessible route.
**Route-level metrics.** The frozen bundle reports modeled shade coverage, direct-sun minutes, detour, duration, step-free status, water stops, and bench stops for each route at four times. At 16:00 the accessible route gives 43.8% shade and 3.3 direct-sun minutes for a 438.2 m / 5.8 min walk, +21.9% detour against the shortest route, with no ramp and two water and six bench stops. The shortest route is lower in total sun (2.7 minutes) but uses the 15% ramp. The shaded route is the longest (732.3 m, +103.7%) and has the most sun (4.9 minutes) despite having the highest shade share at 16:00 (50.0%). The route-level goals are therefore met in part: the accessible option meets the access and shade-share target, not the minimum-sun target; the shortest option meets minimum sun, not the no-ramp target. Reporting both numbers is the point. Step-free continuity is from OSM tags, not a field survey.
**City-level ranking.** The cooling-gap index will be reported as a rank across the eight catchments with a one-line reason, plus the input layers. The rank is **TBD**. The evaluation will show the sensitivity of the rank to the shade/access weights and to the vulnerability input; a rank that flips under plausible weights is not a decision-grade result.
**City-level screening.** The eight catchments score from 0.6471 (Hagenbuchersee 2) to 0.2660 (Density 01). Ranks 1 and 2 are a co-priority (0.0165 apart, 2.5%), and the top-3 set is stable under the tested weight variants. The sensitivity analysis shows the screening is not decision-grade for individual positions 2–3 under shade-heavy weights, but the top-3 priority set is stable. This is a **relative socio-spatial screening index over eight inner-city catchments**, not a citywide neighbourhood ranking and not a measured heat map.
**System metrics.** The inherited SSE path was measured at **120/120 connections opened and closed, zero errors, p95 event 331 ms, p95 scenario 646 ms, presenter POST 49.60 ms, over 4m57.9s** on v1.1. The Cool City route page and vote endpoint are new: their latency, vote tally accuracy, and stage behavior are **TBD**. The retail plan module’s cold generation is 19 ms; that number belongs to the retail module, not the route layer.
@@ -110,38 +122,39 @@ The existing staffing plan remains a separate module. The same forecast schedule
| Evaluation layer | Metrics | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Route | Shade coverage, direct-sun minutes, detour, step-free continuity, water/bench stops | TBD |
| City | Cooling-gap rank, input layers, weight sensitivity | TBD |
| Route | Shade 43.8–50.0%, direct sun 2.7–4.9 min at 16:00, detour 0 to +103.7%, stops, steps | Measured on frozen bundle |
| Screening | Score 0.2660–0.6471; top-3 stable; ranks 1–2 co-priority; vulnerability constant | Ranked; sensitivity run |
| System | SSE 120/120, p95 event 331 ms, p95 scenario 646 ms, presenter 49.60 ms | Measured on inherited v1.1 path |
| Vote / route page | Open success, tally accuracy, route render latency | TBD |
| Comprehension | Task success, explanation quality, route preference | Plan only; TBD |
*Table 3. Evaluation status. Shade is modeled; the cooling gap is relative; no temperature or causal claim is made.*
*Table 4. Evaluation status. Shade is modeled; the screening index is relative and socio-spatial; no temperature or causal claim is made.*
## 5. Privacy and limits
Cool City uses aggregate device counts only. It does not store MAC addresses or PII, does not require accounts, and does not upload a visitor’s location. The audience vote is aggregate; a random session ID in local storage is enough. A production deployment needs a DPIA and a documented legal basis before collecting MAC-derived counts, with the city as controller and a legal review before launch. The existing index is estimated devices, not people; device penetration is unknown; the 0.7 factor is unvalidated; and only 28.2% of 15-minute slots in the 18 June panel have all eight sensors.
The route layer has its own limits. Shade is modeled from buildings and tree crowns, not measured with radiometers; tree cadastre and OSM coverage are incomplete; OSM is a 14 November 2026 snapshot, not an official city dataset; and the route geometry and place names still need verification. The cooling-gap index is a relative ranking, not a measured temperature map, and it does not establish that an intervention will cause a health improvement. We make no “4 °C cooler” claim and no causal claim for shade, water, or bench interventions. The current prototype is a decision-support layer over a noisy index, not a validated public-health instrument.
The route layer has its own limits. Shade is modeled from buildings and tree crowns, not measured with radiometers. **445 of 854 main building footprints use type-default heights** (the 12 m default alone covers 314), tree heights are inferred from crown diameter, the model is 2D in plan view, and clear-sky geometry ignores clouds, awnings, facade reflections, and indoor shade. The bundle flags the **42.6% shade / 5.6 direct-sun minutes for the shaded route at 14:00** as its least-certain value. OSM is a 14 November 2026 snapshot, not an official city dataset; benches, water, toilets, and kerb tags may be incomplete; step-free status comes from tags, not a field survey; the accessible route’s last 34 m is cobblestone; and the Deutschhof courtyard is an out-and-back. The route metrics are suitable for comparing options, not for safety or medical advice.
The screening index has separate limits. Catchments are Euclidean 300 m circles, not network isochrones, and do not model the Neckar, rail, or major-road barriers. Footfall semantics—unit, metric, and aggregation interval—are assumed because the API does not document them. The shade component is a footprint/canopy-share proxy without building heights or solar geometry; it is not the route-level shadow model. Step-free access is proxied by distance to a `wheelchair=yes` POI, not a barrier-free route. Vulnerability is a **2016 district-level 65+ share, constant across all eight catchments**; it does not vary at catchment scale and does not differentiate them. All eight sensors sit within ~585 m and catchments overlap by up to 87.8%, so the screening is relative and local, not a citywide neighbourhood ranking. It does not establish that an intervention will cause a health improvement. We make no “4 °C cooler” claim and no causal claim for shade, water, or bench interventions. The current prototype is a decision-support layer over a noisy index, not a validated public-health instrument.
## 6. Future
The next step is a city-owned public trust: the city controls the route and cooling-gap layer, the underlying data is open where licensing allows (tree cadastre, OSM, city cool places, aggregate population), and the retail module is a commercial tenant rather than the product’s owner. The route/shade bundle and the cooling-gap weights should be published with the paper, tested with older adults and caregivers, and transferred to a second city with a different street network. Field validation of modeled shade and a small route-choice study would turn the current design into evidence. The long-term vision is a public heat-safe wayfinding layer that any city can adopt, with the retail staffing module as one paying application.
The next step is a city-owned public trust: the city controls the route and screening layer, the underlying data is open where licensing allows (tree cadastre, OSM, city cool places, aggregate population), and the retail module is a commercial tenant rather than the product’s owner. The route/shade bundle—3 routes, 12 route/time records, 35 segments, 92 place features, 87.5 KiB—and the screening weights are published with the paper, tested with older adults and caregivers, and transferred to a second city with a different street network. Field validation of modeled shade and a small route-choice study would turn the current design into evidence. The long-term vision is a public heat-safe wayfinding layer that any city can adopt, with the retail staffing module as one paying application.
## 7. TBD register
| Item | Why it is TBD | Next step |
|---|---|---|
| `/cool` route deployment | The route/shade bundle is not frozen | Verify the live `/cool` page and fallback |
| Route geometry (Deutschhof / Kiliansplatz, step-free continuity) | OSM tags and passage geometry need field verification | Walk the route; check steps, crossings, water, benches |
| Route metrics (shade %, direct-sun min, detour, duration, stops) | Route/shade bundle not frozen | Freeze the bundle; report values on the four time slices |
| Cooling-gap weights and rank | City bundle and weight sensitivity not frozen | Publish weights; run sensitivity; report rank and reason |
| Vote / route-page latency | New endpoint not measured | Run the same k6/SSE protocol; report open success and p95 |
| `/cool` route deployment | The bundle is frozen, but the live page and its fallback were not verified for this paper | Verify the deployed `/cool` page, failure state, and data version |
| Vote / route-page latency | New endpoint not measured | Run the same k6/SSE protocol; report open success, tally accuracy, and p95 |
| Comprehension test | Plan only; no participants yet | Recruit older adults/caregivers with the city; publish tasks and results |
| Field verification of tags and surfaces | Step-free status, kerb/ramp, water, bench, and toilet tags are OSM-based, not surveyed; the accessible route’s last 34 m is cobblestone | Walk all three routes; check the 15% ramp, the tunnel, and the toilet tags |
| Field validation of modeled shade | Clear-sky 2D geometry with default building heights and inferred tree heights | Radiometer transects on the same routes; compare modeled and measured direct sun |
| Production licence for city-map layers | The official cool-place, toilet, and water layers have no explicit open-data licence | Confirm permission with the city before production |
| DOI | Event draft has no DOI yet | Mint on Zenodo after the event |
| OSM/tree coverage | 14 Nov 2026 OSM snapshot; cadastre may be incomplete | Document query date; compare with city tree data |
*Table 4. Open items. These are deliberately not filled with plausible-looking numbers.*
*Table 5. Open items. These are deliberately not filled with plausible-looking numbers.*
## References