Files
OKF_Vault/knowledge/challenges/stadt-heilbronn-cable-car-sentiment.md
T
Noel Sabia 7b9893a89e feat: add OKF knowledge bundle for hackathon challenges
Capture all six Future City Hackathon 2026 challenges as OKF v0.2 concepts, with dataset and organizer concepts, indexes, and a log.

Configure release-please with the simple strategy so the first release PR bumps the repository from 0.0.0 to 0.1.0.
2026-11-13 18:23:00 +01:00

172 lines
8.9 KiB
Markdown

---
type: Hackathon Challenge
title: "Riding the Sentiment: public opinion on urban cable cars"
description: Analyze two years of social media and news coverage to show how Heilbronn's planned cable car is discussed, how the debate changes over time, and how it compares with other projects.
resource: ../../Stadt%20Heilbronn/readme%20Seilbahn_Challenge.docx
tags: [hackathon, future-city-hackathon-2026, stadt-heilbronn, cable-car, sentiment, stance-detection, nlp, dashboard]
status: stable
generated: { by: opencode/deepseek-v4.1-flash, at: 2026-11-13T17:13:56Z }
sources:
- id: seilbahn-readme
resource: ../../Stadt%20Heilbronn/readme%20Seilbahn_Challenge.docx
title: "Riding the Sentiment — Seilbahn challenge README"
author: team:stadt-heilbronn
- id: seilbahn-deck
resource: ../../Stadt%20Heilbronn/Pitch%20%20Seilbahn_Challenge.pptx
title: "Riding the Sentiment — challenge pitch"
author: team:stadt-heilbronn
- id: seilbahn-data
resource: ../../Stadt%20Heilbronn/FSI_Heilbronn_Medienbeitr%C3%A4ge%20(1).json
title: "FSI Heilbronn Medienbeiträge — media mention dataset"
---
# At a glance
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Organizer | [Stadt Heilbronn](/organizers/stadt-heilbronn.md) |
| Project | A planned urban cable car connecting Heilbronn with the IPAI campus |
| Data | About two years of public social media and news content |
| Comparison cases | Câble C1 in the Paris region, the planned cable car in Bonn, and the IPAI campus in Heilbronn |
| Output | An interactive dashboard plus three to five key insights for Heilbronn |
| Core skill | Turning thousands of individual voices into a clear, traceable picture of public debate |
# The problem
Large urban infrastructure projects trigger very different reactions. Some people see new opportunities for sustainable mobility and urban development; others question costs, benefits, feasibility, or priorities. The City of Heilbronn is planning an urban cable car as an extension of public transport, connecting the city with the IPAI campus. The question is: what does the public actually think?[^seilbahn-readme]
Raw sentiment is not enough. A negative-sounding statement does not necessarily mean opposition to the project, so the brief asks teams to consider **stance towards the project** as well as sentiment.[^seilbahn-readme]
# Your task
## 1 — Explore
Explore the public debate around Heilbronn's planned cable car. Look for patterns in social media posts, comments, and news coverage, and identify the topics, arguments, and concerns that shape the discussion.[^seilbahn-readme]
Possible questions:
- What are the main topics and discussion points?
- Which arguments are used for or against the project?
- Are reactions predominantly supportive, critical, neutral, or undecided?
- Are there recurring concerns or expectations?
- Do social media discussions differ from news coverage?
Go beyond simple positive-versus-negative sentiment and examine stance towards the project.
## 2 — Compare
Put the Heilbronn debate into perspective with other projects:[^seilbahn-readme]
- An operating urban cable car, such as the **Câble C1** in the Paris region.
- Another planned cable-car project, such as the one in **Bonn**.
- A different major development project in Heilbronn, such as the **IPAI campus**.
Questions:
- Are reactions similar across cities and projects?
- Are certain topics typical for urban cable cars regardless of location?
- Which concerns or expectations are specific to Heilbronn?
- Is an unusual transport system discussed differently from another major urban project such as IPAI?
- Do projects at different stages, from planning to construction and operation, generate different types of debate?
## 3 — Track
Public opinion is not static. Analyze how the discussion develops over time, identify moments when attention suddenly increases or reactions change, and connect those patterns with real-world developments such as:[^seilbahn-readme]
- Political decisions and announcements.
- New cost estimates.
- Route or planning changes.
- Visualisations of the project.
- Construction milestones.
- Media reports.
- The opening of a new system.
Then ask what happens afterwards: does the discussion quickly return to normal, or does the event change the debate more permanently?
## 4 — Visualize
Turn the findings into an interactive and engaging dashboard. It should let users explore the debate rather than only display a few aggregated indicators. Make visible:[^seilbahn-readme]
- How much people are talking about a project.
- What they are talking about.
- How they react.
- How opinions and topics change over time.
- Which events trigger reactions.
- How different projects and cities compare.
Users should be able to move from an overall picture to individual topics, periods, or projects and understand what is driving the patterns they see.
# What you get
The package contains [Stadt Heilbronn media mentions](/data/stadt-heilbronn-media-mentions.md): 39,361 records published between 2024-10-19 and 2026-10-27. The data was collected from publicly accessible content without requiring a login and without circumventing technical access restrictions. Direct personal identifiers are not included.[^seilbahn-readme]
The dataset was pre-filtered with a small keyword set:
- `IPAI` for discussions related to the IPAI project in Heilbronn.
- `Seilbahn` for German-language discussions related to cable cars.
- `téléphérique` for discussions around the cable car project in Paris.
Keyword filtering does not mean every post is relevant. Broad terms such as `Seilbahn` or `téléphérique` also capture tourist cable cars, toys, and unrelated projects, so further filtering and identifying which posts belong to the projects of interest is part of the challenge.[^seilbahn-readme]
## Data caveats
- The dataset is a media-monitoring export, not a representative survey. Conclusions should describe the observed conversation, not the whole population.
- The `sentiment` field uses a small integer scale and includes `-99` as a distinct sentinel value. Treat it as unknown or unclassified rather than as an extreme negative score unless you can verify its meaning.
- `reach` is missing for some records; `engagements` is available but may be zero or platform-specific.
- Records span many media types (news, YouTube videos and comments, forums, blogs, social networks) and several languages. Normalise before comparing.
- Duplicate or near-duplicate content is possible across sources.
# Methods
The brief says there is no single correct approach. Suggested methods include:[^seilbahn-readme]
- Natural Language Processing.
- Sentiment analysis.
- Stance detection.
- Topic modelling.
- Embedding-based clustering.
- Keyword and argument analysis.
- Named entity recognition.
- Temporal analysis.
- Peak or change-point detection.
- LLM-based text classification.
- Interactive data visualisation.
Whatever the approach, results must remain understandable and traceable. A sophisticated model is only useful if users can understand what the results mean.[^seilbahn-readme]
# Expected outcome
The brief lists these expected elements:[^seilbahn-readme]
- A reproducible approach for processing and analyzing unstructured text data.
- A meaningful classification of the major discussion topics.
- An analysis of sentiment and/or stance towards the projects.
- A temporal view of how the debate develops.
- Identification of relevant events and reaction peaks.
- Comparisons between cities and projects.
- An interactive dashboard that communicates the results clearly.
- Three to five key insights that Heilbronn can take away from the analysis.
The final result should combine data analysis and storytelling: not just numbers, but the patterns behind them.[^seilbahn-readme]
# Responsible data use
Teams may collect additional data, but the brief requires them to respect data protection and privacy, comply with platform terms and technical access restrictions, collect only what is necessary, avoid exposing personal information in the dashboard, and document where additional data comes from and how it was collected.[^seilbahn-readme]
# What makes a strong solution
- A clear, defensible definition of relevance, topic, sentiment, and stance.
- A pipeline that another person could reproduce.
- A temporal story tied to real events, not just a line chart.
- Comparisons that explain what is specific to Heilbronn.
- A dashboard that supports exploration from overview to detail.
- Insights a city administration could actually use.
# Sources
The README is the detailed brief.[^seilbahn-readme] The pitch deck summarises the challenge.[^seilbahn-deck] Dataset facts come from the delivered JSON export.[^seilbahn-data]
[^seilbahn-readme]: Stadt Heilbronn, "Riding the Sentiment: Exploring Public Opinion on Urban Cable Cars", challenge README, 2026.
[^seilbahn-deck]: Stadt Heilbronn, "Riding the Sentiment", challenge pitch deck, 2026.
[^seilbahn-data]: FSI Heilbronn, `FSI_Heilbronn_Medienbeiträge (1).json`, delivered media mention export, 2026.